Become a Member
Recipes

Recipe: Arbequina olive oil ice cream

There's more to Chanukah than fried doughnuts - use your olive oil in this delicious dessert

December 8, 2022 12:21
EVOO cake icecream - JC 22-11-2022 ice cream only 0011
2 min read

Cook: 20 - 30 mins plus chilling/freezing time (overnight minimum)

Serves: Makes 1 litre

In the 20 years I’ve been testing new recipes out on long-suffering friends and family, this has most surprised and delighted my critics. I mention this because this exquisitely smooth, luxurious ice cream doesn’t fit the ‘quick and easy” mould of many contemporary recipes. 

Patience in the kitchen has never been my own forte, but on a gloomy winter’s day, devoting fifteen or twenty minutes to patiently cooking a perfect custard has proved to be calming, Zen-like experience. I promise, your efforts will be rewarded by surprised and delighted diners. Served with my lemon olive oil cake it’s a sublime combination.

Be sure to use a mild, fruity extra virgin olive oil, without any bitterness - ideally from Arbequina olives. I’ve had great success using supermarket brand “best” Spanish unfiltered extra virgin, or branded oil labelled “Early Harvest (Arbequina).” 

Ingredients

700ml whole milk 

230ml double cream 

6 egg yolks

200g golden caster sugar 

½ tsp fine sea salt 

160ml mild, fruity extra virgin olive oil plus 1 tbsp extra for serving 

Flaked sea salt for serving, optional