Become a Member
The Jewish Chronicle

Try America’s new dream, Israel

With Obama in, Israelis now need to elect another dove — Livni — for the peace process to have a chance.

November 6, 2008 11:12

ByJonathan Freedland, Jonathan Freedland

3 min read

As one marathon election campaign ends, another begins. Though something tells me the world will not be following the battle of Tzipi Livni and Bibi Netanyahu - which will rage from now until February - with anything like the obsessive interest they showed in the clash of Barack Obama and John McCain.

Not that the Israeli contest will be lacking in drama. Bibi is just as ready to fight dirty as McCain was, while Livni's candidacy will be (sort of) historic. Ok, not a first like President-Elect Obama but for Livni to become Israel's second woman prime minister is not nothing.

And the stakes are high too. The leadership of the free world may not be at stake, as it was in the US, but the future of the Middle East may well be. Livni will go into the coming campaign as the peace candidate. She has been Israel's lead negotiator in the talks that have ground on for more than a year: by all accounts she is formidably good at it, serious and focused. Bibi, by contrast, is still the Mr No of Israeli politics, finding new ways to send the same old, negative message. His latest contribution to the peace effort? To insist that all of Jerusalem must stay permanently under Israeli control - even though everyone serious about peace knows that, eventually, the Arab neighbourhoods of Jerusalem will become part of Palestine, just as the Jewish neighbourhoods will remain part of Israel.

But there is a more substantial connection between these two elections - US and Israeli - than the relay-style baton-passing from one to the other; one may well affect the other. Recent history suggests that one of the very few external pressures that can influence Israeli public opinion is the threat of falling out with the United States. Let's face it, Israelis couldn't care less what Europeans think. But they do listen to the US. And they don't like being on the wrong side of them.