Become a Member
Opinion

The Israeli train now arriving at platform one is 50 years late

The opening of the Tel Aviv urban area light-rail system this week symbolises how a nation at the cutting edge of tech and defence innovation can also tie itself in knots over simple advances

August 24, 2023 11:57
Benjamin Netanyahu Attending the Dedication Ceremony for the Tel Aviv Metropolitan Area Light Rail 1 F230817KOKO03
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, his wife Sara and Ministers at the opening ceremony of the light rail, in Petah Tikva, August 17, 2023. Photo by KOKO/POOL *** Local Caption *** טקס רכבת קלה פתח תקווה בנימין נתניהו שרה נתניהו
6 min read

Fifty is a nice round number. When the brand-new Tel Aviv urban area light-rail system finally opened last week, all the news stories referred to a decision made by the Golda Meir government in April 1973 as the start of the project, making it a round half-century from inception to completion.

But dates are as movable as goalposts and there are any number of dates stretching back to the pre-independence era and all the way forward to the start of the current century when the project, which has been through an interminable series of stops and starts, can be said to have begun.

But 50 years fits, especially when you compare it to other complex Israeli projects.

It symbolises so many things about the country that took 50 years to build the first light-rail line, using technology that has been around since the 19th century, in its largest urban area (the Red Line opened last week is just one of three lines currently planned, and no one is taking bets when the next two will be ready), while the Iron Dome missile defence system, which was totally innovative in just about everything it does, took only five years from original concept to first operational use.

The ironies and symbolisms just pile up. At the official opening ceremony of what is supposed to solve at least part of Tel Aviv’s congestion problems, dozens of streets in the city were closed “for security reasons” so that Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu could speak at the ceremony. His government routinely complains that the police allow the pro-democracy protesters (who were, of course, protesting again, though at a prescribed distance) to block roads in Tel Aviv.

And while the government put on a big show, the local government, personified by Tel Aviv’s veteran mayor Ron Huldai, boycotted the event in protest at the light-rail not operating on Shabbat, as “it should in a liberal and democratic state”, according to Huldai.

By the way, if 50 years sounds like a long time to wait for a mass-transportation network, it’s positively short-term when compared to the Tel Aviv underground, which was first mooted in the 1930s back in the days of the British Mandate.