Become a Member

Norman Lebrecht

By


Norman Lebrecht,

norman lebrecht

Opinion

I’ll skip the ‘unlimited exercise’ if you don’t mind, Boris

Being of an over-literal disposition, Jews take government edicts personally, says Norman Lebrecht

May 28, 2020 13:59
Lockdown exercise
A woman jogs past Buckingham Palace in central London on May 26, 2020, as lockdown measures are eased during the novel coronavirus COVID-19 pandemic. (Photo by JUSTIN TALLIS / AFP) (Photo by JUSTIN TALLIS/AFP via Getty Images)
3 min read

Barely were the words ‘unlimited exercise’ out of Boris’s mouth than I knew we were in for more pain than gain. Being of an over-literal disposition, Jews take government edicts personally.

The rabbinic injunction dina demalchuta dina comes into play. It might turn up on Google Translate as ‘Diana should have been Queen’, but every halachic Jew bar N16 black hats on Lag Ba’omer night gets the idea that you go along with a government order no matter how much it hurts.

If the Tsar says ‘exercise’, that means press-ups. If he says ‘unlimited’ that’ll be morning to night.

This new situation will be painful for us in more than the obvious ways. Jews are not designed for exercise. In my book Genius and Anxiety, I report the horror experienced by the head of a Lithuanian yeshiva at seeing his boys playing football in their lunch break.