closeicon
News

Luciana Berger called 'disruptive Zionist' by Labour member proposing no confidence motion in her

The Liverpool Wavertree MP faces the motion for criticising Jeremy Corbyn's failure to deal with Jew-hate

articlemain

UPDATE: The no confidence motions against Luciana Berger were withdrawn late on Friday afternoon

A Labour member proposing a motion of no confidence in Jewish MP Luciana Berger previously called her a "disruptive Zionist", it has been revealed.

The MP, who is the parliamentary chair of Jewish Labour Movement, faces two motions against her, to be debated by her Liverpool Wavertree party members on February 17.

They accuse her of "continually using the media to criticise the man we all want to be prime minister".

It has since emerged that the proposer of one of the motions, Kenneth Campbell, has called her a "disruptive Zionist" and shared a Facebook post that called Jewish Labour MP Dame Margaret Hodge "utterly shameless", the Hurry Up Harry blog revealed.

He proposed the second of the two motions, which says Ms Berger is "continiously criticising our leader when she should be working towards a general election". 

In July 2017, he wrote on Facebook Ms Berger should be "exposed for the disruptive Zionist she is".

Labour Deputy Leader Tom Watson has condemned those pushing the confidence motions against Ms Berger, saying they "bring disgrace to the party that I love".

He told the Commons: "As we unify and commit to support this bill, let us not forget our honourable colleagues on both sides of the House, the subject of death threats, the subject of racist abuse, the subject of misogynistic abuse, the subject of bullying and antisemitism.

"Let me say to the honourable colleagues facing that abuse, and in particular my friend and comrade the member for Liverpool Wavertree, that she has our solidarity, our support, as she battles the bullying and hatred from members of her own local party."

Meanwhile, John McDonnell reacted to the motions by demanding Ms Berger reject rumours she was considering leaving Labour.

The shadow chancellor said they were to do with recent media reports that Ms Berger was poised to quit the party and form a break-away party.

He told BBC Radio Four's Today programme: "It's not a deselection... It's an expression of views. If people are doing that because she's stood up against antisemitism, that's completely wrong."

But he said this was not the case on this motion, "from what I've seen on social media".

He added: "Luciana has been associated in the media with a break away party... the media have asked her to deny that and she hasn’t been clear on that.

"So, my advice to Luciana is just tell people you're not leaving Labour, you're not jumping ship... on all of this is for Luciana to just put this issue to bed."

But Mr McDonnell was condemned on social media for this response.

Holocaust Educational Trust chief executive Karen Pollock called it a "disgrace" that Mr McDonnell was "demanding loyalty... rather than addressing the racism in your party".

Labour MP Chuka Umunna said: "How about demanding her CLP treats her with the respect she deserves. How about the party deals with that racism. Words fail me. Totally unacceptable."

 

Share via

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive