Become a Member
News

Three statements now posted at entrance to controversial Whitworth exhibition

Original statement was withdrawn then reinstated after counter-statement posted, which has now prompted a counter-counter-statement

August 22, 2021 12:10
Image.jpg
2 min read

The controversial “Cloud Studies” exhibition at Manchester’s Whitworth Art Gallery has descended into a running battle between the show’s creators, the research group Forensic Architecture, and members of the local Jewish community. The exhibition reflects the environmental effects of toxic clouds in places such as Indonesia, Argentina, Hong Kong, the UK, US, Mexico, Turkey, and Lebanon, but it also includes a significant section on Israel’s military action in Gaza and the West Bank.

There are now three separate statements at the entrance to the Whitworth Art Gallery: a Forensic Architecture statement, in which Israel is described as an “apartheid state” which has engaged in “ethnic cleansing” of Palestinians; a counter-statement from the Jewish community; and a counter-counter statement from the International Centre for Justice for Palestinians, giving a legal opinion as to why Forensic Architecture was correct to use such terms.

Last week a printed statement from Forensic Architecture, introducing visitors to the exhibition, was withdrawn by the Whitworth, a part of Manchester University, after protests from the North West Friends of Israel, the Manchester Jewish Representative Council, and UK Lawyers for Israel. The lawyers’ group had complained to Manchester University, querying whether the University had complied with its public sector equality duty to have due regard to the need to foster good relations between different communities”.

Forensic Architecture immediately said that if its opening statement did not appear, then it was demanding the closure of the entire exhibition. The Whitworth agreed, and after a temporary closure the Cloud Studies show re-opened on Wednesday — together with the Forensic Architecture original statement, in which Israel is described as “an apartheid state” which has engaged in “ethnic cleansing”.

More from News

More from News