The group tried to lose the promoter by walking away without engaging in a confrontation.
By this point, Stephen, the only member of the trio wearing a yarmulke, had taken it off to avoid attention.
When they walked back past the same area, however, men began following them again and asking “intently” if they were from Israel.
Judah said: “We were walking to the car park when two guys appeared out of nowhere. They started shouting, ‘do you like killing babies?’ and ‘do you like Israel?’ I was dumbfounded, not scared.”
David added: “My friend said, ‘no, I’m Christian.’ The guy got in his face and asked if he likes killing kids. My friend said again that he’s a Christian, then the guy punched [him] in the face.”
The men were unable to prevent the assault because it seemed to come out of nowhere, they said.
“While one was talking to me, another one punched my face,” Judah said.
“I tried to clench my fist to respond, and he hit me again. Then I fell onto the floor, and while I was trying to stand up, I fell back down again.”
Despite David screaming for help, men standing outside nearby bars did not react.
Other than some bruising, Judah said, he was not injured following the incident.
David added: “I think there’s a little bit of shock in terms of what we experienced.
"We didn’t want to make the rest of our trip about that, but it was hard not to. We did our best to have a good time, we did whale watching and hiked on the volcano, but we limited our interaction with locals as a result.”
Both men said they would be more circumspect about being visibly Jewish in public when abroad in future.
Speaking to Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez in October, Isaac Benzaquén, president of the Federation of Jewish Communities of Spain, said the country had seen the sharpest rise in antisemitism in its history following the October 7 attack.
“Demonstrations against Israel, the burning of Israeli flags, the proclamations calling Israel a murderer, genocidal and the author of a planned ethnic cleansing, as Minister [of Social Rights] Ione Belarra has reiterated on several occasions, have inflamed the mood against the Spanish Jewish community, as we have seen in Melilla, Barcelona and Madrid, among other cities,” the federation said in a statement.
Some synagogues and Jewish community centres have closed while schools have received protection, Benzaquén said.
Eighty per cent of Jews feel less safe in the UK than they did before Hamas’s attacks on Israel two months ago, polling commissioned by the Jewish Leadership Council and published earlier this month has revealed.
More than a quarter of British Jews say they have experienced antisemitic abuse over the same period.
