closeicon
Israel

Reform Jews are ‘mentally ill’ says Charedi MK

Charedi insult follows ‘clown’ jibe and conversion row over state-run mikvaot

articlemain

Reform Jews in Israel are livid after a Charedi politician likened their religious authorities to people with mental illness.

Charedi leaders were devastated last week after hearing that people converting to Judaism with the Reform movement will now be able to complete the process at state-run ritual baths. The High Court ended their exclusion.

On Monday, Israel Eichler of the United Torah Judaism party ramped the rhetoric against the decision to a new high.

"Not every mentally ill person can come to the operating room and decide the rules of medicine and force the hospital to have an operation by whatever way works," he wrote in a request for the ritual-bath ruling to be debated in the Knesset.

In a parallel move, his party initiated a bill intended to cancel out the effect of the court ruling, and attracted the support of some religious-Zionist politicians in response.

The head of Israel's Reform Movement, Gilad Kariv, referred to Mr Eicher's comments as part of growing "incitement" against his movement.

It comes on the heels of other strongly worded comments about Reform Jews, including the jibe that they are "clowns stabbing the holy Torah", made last month by Mr Eichler's party colleague, Moshe Gafni.

The trigger for the clown comment was clear - it was the state's decision to award non-Orthodox movements a special section at the Western Wall for mixed-gender prayer, which Charedi politicians saw as a public humiliation.

But ritual baths, where people normally immerse privately? Why such an extreme reaction?

The reason is that the end-of-conversion immersion is the point where a person becomes Jewish, and allowing Reform to do this in state facilities seems to them like a step towards state recognition for Reform conversions. It feels - to the Charedim - like a massive blow in that old battle over the question of "who is a Jew?".

For years, Charedi leaders have been likening Reform rabbis to untrained doctors, claiming that, as a fake medic may suggest a phoney cure, Reform rabbis recommend bogus religious practices.

The utter rage over the ritual baths ruling has caused Mr Eichler to change his controversial analogy and demote the Reform rabbi from phoney doctor to self-prescribing mental patient.

Share via

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive