Is campus free speech bill an ‘opportunity’ for Shoah deniers? Jewish groups ask for clarity

The Community Security Trust called for measures to protect Jewish students in a statement to the JC. 

“We hope these proposals include appropriate measures so that the essential right to free speech is balanced with the rights of Jewish students not to be subjected to antisemitism at their university, whether this is from fellow students, visiting speakers or academics and lecturers. 

“We also hope that Jewish Societies will be protected from the kind of onerous security costs imposed by some universities in the past, that have made it impossible for some Jewish Societies to host visiting speakers from Israel because of the threat that their meetings will be disrupted by extremists,” the organisation said.

Mr Williamson told MPs on Monday the bill “will not and never will create a platform for Holocaust deniers”, citing protections against hate speech enshrined in existing legislation. 

“The 1986 Public Order Act, the 2010 Equality Act, introduced by Labour, as well as the Prevent duties in 2015 – this bill if made an act will not create the space to tolerate Holocaust deniers and never shall,” he said. 

Media lawyer Mark Lewis said he did not believe neo-Nazi claimants would receive damages should a claim be brought forward and added that “sunlight will be the best disinfectant.”

“I’d sooner have a law that permits JSocs and risks the occasional neo-Nazi to speak to a near empty audience where sunlight will be the best disinfectant,” he said.

The Union of Jewish Students said it was working closely with communal groups and government.