closeicon
News

Home Secretary rules on case of Charedi man facing extradition to Israel

Efraim Fishel Grinfeld is wanted in Israel on charges of rioting outside an electronics shop in Jerusalem

articlemain

The Home Secretary has ruled that an Orthodox man who fled to Britain facing charges connected to a violent protest outside a Jerusalem electronics shop can be sent back to Israel to face justice.

A High Court ruling meant Suella Braverman was free to rule on whether he should be extradited to Israel to finally face judgment over the incident 15 years ago.

Efraim Fishel Grinfeld fled Israel in 2012 shortly before a court was due to deliver a verdict on his role in the protest.

Grinfeld was accused of rioting outside a store selling DVD and MP3 players in the strictly Orthodox neighbourhood of Geula between June and August 2008.

According to the extradition request made by the Israeli authorities, Grinfeld was part of a group of up to 20 people who obstructed the entrance to the store, shoved and threatened customers and tried to prevent people from shopping.

The group were also accused of cursing and pushing employees and the store owners. They also allegedly vandalised the store and its merchandise and threw dirty babies’ nappies at the shop entrance.

Grinfeld, who does not speak English, was said to “have cut off the electricity in the store so that he could vandalise under the cover of darkness” and “shoved, punched and kicked employees who tried to prevent his actions”. A rock was also thrown during the protest.

He had been charged in Israel with seven offences, including riot, common assault, blackmail by threats and wounding under aggravating circumstances.

At his original trial, Grinfeld, a Yiddish speaker, denied taking part in the violence and said he had merely sat and read psalms during the incident.

However, while awaiting the verdict, Grinfeld left Israel with his wife and their then three children for Canada before settling in London in 2016 where he worked as an office assistant at a property business, according to a High Court decision published last week.

While the judge took into account that Grinfeld had led a “settled and law-abiding life in the UK”, he also considered him a “fugitive from justice”.

Grinfeld, who now has eight children, including a six-month-old baby, challenged the decision, claimed that prison conditions in Israel would violate his human rights and that extraditing him would have a disproportionate impact on his family.

He had appealed to the High Court over a judge’s earlier decision to refer the case to the Home Secretary for a final ruling.

After Braverman's later ruling following the High Court decision to refer to the Home Secretary, Grinfield is able to appeal to the Supreme Court on the case.

Share via

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive