closeicon

Jenni Frazer

Real life Bad Jews should be fodder for Jewish actors

Stephen Pollard is wrong to say only Tom Hardy could play Alfie Solomons

articlemain
January 12, 2022 13:33

My esteemed erstwhile colleague Stephen Pollard has entered the always volatile Jewface debate with an impassioned defence of the actor Tom Hardy, who plays the Jewish character Alfie Solomons in the BBC’s Peaky Blinders.

He was nearly convincing me with his argument about Hardy — “about as Jewish as bacon” — until I reached his conclusion that “here we have an explicitly and crucially Jewish role which needs to be played by a non-Jewish actor”.

And I thought — why is that? Why does this role, full of brimming and explosive violence, need to be played by a non-Jewish actor? Surely Stephen cannot be suggesting that Jews can’t play violent?

I daresay the late and much mourned Antony Sher could have given Tom Hardy a run for his money in the festering violence stakes. Or even, if we can stretch out our casting wand to the international, such heavyweight Jewish actors, back in their heyday, as Kirk Douglas or Edward G Robinson.

But it is true, probably, that Jewish actors in today’s Britain are unlikely to be playing parts full of menace. And I wondered why that is. Are Jews thought of as too thoroughly genial, too full of goodwill, to convince an audience of their hatefulness in a role? Or is there discomfort on the part of the actors themselves?

Unfortunately we all know too many examples of bad Jews in real life, never mind on the stage. I’d like to think that in a drama school not very far away there is a young character actor desperate to cut his metaphorical teeth on playing Jewish bad guys.

And if that happens then talk of antisemitism and Jewface can fall by the wayside. Because, after all, it’s only acting, isn’t it?


January 12, 2022 13:33

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive