I think it should be clear that my political views vis a vis Israel are not exactly what one would call "left wing". Then again, I certainly wouldn't want to ally myself with anyone from the right who believes in going around shooting Arabs.
So I suppose I'm stuck somewhere in the middle, or probably to the right of centre. I support the Jewish Settlers in their ideals to live in whichever part of Israel they choose to do so. I don't however agree with the actions of some of the hotheads who go out of their way to antagonise their Palestinian neighbours. I also strongly believe that places like Hebron must always remain in Jewish hands, irrespective of whether the UN or anyone else for that matter agrees with it or not.
I write this in light of (Vice Premier) Haim Ramon's evacuation-compensation bill which offers to pay off the Settlers to the tune of 1.1 million shekels (nearly £170,180) per family, on the condition that they voluntarily agree to move to the Negev or Galilee (with extra incentives for the latter).
If I were a settler, I would find such an offer extraordinarily insulting. These people risk their lives on a daily basis to follow their ideal. Yes, there are those who moved the settlements for economic reasons, but I'd like to believe that the vast majority aren't in it for the money.
Jewish ministers offering bribes to Jewish settlers to move out is both insulting and degrading to all concerned and Ramon, frankly should be thoroughly ashamed of his actions.
Read Next
Judaism taught the West to think – now it must teach it how to survive
In extracts from her new book, The Builder’s Stone, Melanie Phillips explains how Jewish nationhood, education and morality can play a vital role in shaping the future
Seriously? Again with the judicial reform?
Israel cannot afford to be distracted by more internal power struggles and pointless ideological crusades
The Met must stand firm against the Gaza marchers
The JC Leader, January 17 2025
Real Holocaust remembrance requires standing up for Israel
You can’t really believe in the importance and implications of the Holocaust without understanding Israel’s essential legitimacy
We can keep hope alive for two states while being realistic
There are times in human history when pressure from above changes the political geography for the better – when superpowers call the shots. This may be such a time.
Have the JC delivered to your door
Want more from the JC?
To continue reading, we just need a few details...
Get the best news and views
from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our
partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and
archive
from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our
partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and
archive
©2025 The Jewish Chronicle