Become a Member
Letters

The JC Letters Page, 30th August 2019

Jeremey Havardi, Melvyn Lipitch, Cllr Brian Gordon, Harry Levy, Dr Anthony Isaacs, Neville Landau and Shemer Isbitz share their views with JC readers

August 30, 2019 10:27
Letters.PNG
4 min read

Democrats, Israel, Trump — and the JC

Maya Ilany (JC, August 23) condemns Israel’s decision to ban US Reps Tlaib and Omar because they were denied the chance to “meet Israelis and Palestinians whose daily lives are impacted by the conflict and occupation.” 


This reasoning is highly flawed. Judging by their itinerary, neither politician planned to visit Israelis living with the daily pain of conflict and terror. Instead, they sought to meet only Arab and Palestinian politicians, so as to further their agenda of demonising, delegitimising and boycotting the Jewish state. Nor is it true that Tlaib and Omar are merely “no great fans of the Israeli government.” Omar has expressed antisemitic views that question the loyalty of American Jews while Tlaib openly supports a one-state solution that would destroy Israel demographically. 


That said, the ban was misguided, having appeared to be a response to a Twitter request from President Trump. But, like any democracy, Israel must make its own decisions on who enters the country. 


Let us be under no illusion, however, that Tlaib and Omar are as open-minded as Yachad believe. They are champions of the anti-Israel movement and must be called out for their bias and bigotry.