closeicon

Compromise is the only way forward for Israel

The JC Leader, 28 July 2023

articlemain

2RDXDT3 London, UK. 23rd July, 2023. An estimated 1500 British Israelis protested ahead of the judicial reform vote in the Knesset on Monday, that seeks to limit the powers of the country's Supreme Court. Benjamin Netanyahu's government argues that the changes are needed in order to readdress the balance of power, whereas critics say it will weaken the judiciary and undermine democracy. The protest in London crossed Tower Bridge in solidarity with the tens of thousands marching from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem objecting to the bill. Credit: Eleventh Hour Photography/Alamy Live News

July 27, 2023 10:53

In March, as debate raged over the Israeli government’s proposed judicial reforms, President Herzog warned that the country was on the verge of “civil war”. Since then, the rancour has worsened.

The street protests have increased; this week’s march to Jerusalem was, by a large margin, the biggest such gathering ever seen in Israel. Opinions are not merely polarised.

There is a poisonous atmosphere now in Israel, with both sides becoming ever more entrenched and dogmatic. From the diaspora perspective, whatever view one takes of the proposals, it is impossible to see what is happening in the land we love and not weep. Now more than ever, compromise is vital. The stakes could hardly be higher. These are historic times for Israel and not in a good way. Decisions and actions taken now will determine its future.

The government says it has every right to push ahead with further reforms after Monday’s vote (which removed the so-called reasonableness test), because it is formed of a majority of MKs and thus has democratic legitimacy.

But the only reason this particular coalition exists is because Prime Minister Netanyahu — who is, of course, on trial for corruption — was forced to rely on deals with extremist parties to return to power. Israel is only in this crisis because in order to remain in office, he is doing their bidding.

It is precisely because Israel has no written constitution or upper chamber that judicial issues and decisions are so important. Reforms must not be carried out for the wrong reasons, or with a sledgehammer.

There have always been divisions in Israeli society and politics, but since its founding in 1948, an implicit understanding of the need for compromise and the role of mutual obligation have always kept the divisions in check.

The breakdown of these principles is behind the current crisis. It is more vital than ever that the profound need for compromise and consent is learned anew by both government and opposition.

July 27, 2023 10:53

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive