closeicon

Elia Lévy

As a French Jew, I now feel closer to Israel than ever before

I feel very lucky to be at a Jewish school and to avoid some of the worst antisemitism

articlemain

Policemen are at work near the "Ozar Hatorah" Jewish school, on March 19, 2012 in Toulouse, southwestern France, where four people (three of them children), were killed and two seriously wounded when a gunman opened fire. This is the third gun attack in a week by a man who fled on a motorbike. AFP PHOTO / REMY GABALDA (Photo by REMY GABALDA / AFP) (Photo by REMY GABALDA/AFP via Getty Images)

August 20, 2024 15:02

As a Jewish teenager growing up in the south of France I've always been aware of antisemitism. It's been repeatedly mentioned in Jewish history lessons, regular history lessons and in religious studies classes.

I have never actually experienced any hate attacks because I’m at a Jewish school. I think a Jewish school is the safest place for Jewish children. Just check out the bulletproof doors and police stationed in front.

Many people in my school want to make aliyah. I hear things such as, “I feel safer being in Israel during the war than I do in France”. I understand where this feeling is coming from. I really do. When you've been told all your life by everyone around you that France is a dangerous place for Jews and have seen the many Islamist attacks around the country, the best option would be to move to Israel.

This sentiment has been magnified since October 7. Many of my classmates want to go and fight for a country they don't live in.

The atmosphere here is sombre. My school has invited people from all over to talk to us about the hostages and the war. Many of us cry during these talks. Different “Bring Them Home” posters can be found all around my school, in shuls and scattered around the place we stayed at during camp. They are a loud reminder of Hamas’s atrocities.

We always try to put up hostage photos in the widest areas possible but they seem to not be wanted by passers-by who remove them.

October 7 has changed things for the French Jewish community. Ask any Jewish student on campus and they'll tell you. The protests and bullying allegations are scary and make me wonder if I will ever reveal my Jewish identity to my classmates when I move into higher education. I would definitely not walk outside with an Israeli flag in Marseille - or anywhere in France for that matter.

But it's the little things that have to be hidden because of the danger: Magen David necklaces and youth movement shirts, even the long skirts some girls need to wear for school, which they no longer do in fear of being recognised as Jewish.

I am grateful that I don't go to a non-Jewish state school or I would, I know, have far worse stories to tell. The verbal comments about Palestine my friends in state schools receive aren't pretty and debates are rendered impossible because of running hatred. I look on from afar and try to console them the best I can.

Most of the stuff I've been exposed to is online, on YouTube, TikTok and Instagram, but that’s a pretty universal experience for Jewish teens. It's strange to see my non-Jewish friends’ “All Eyes Oh Rafah” Instagram stories followed by my Jewish friends’ “Bring Them Home” posts. It's a contrast that makes the internal dialogues I have been having since the beginning of the war even more complicated.

I believe that while my future is not in Israel, my heart certainly is. I have definitely felt closer to Israel since October 7 than when I have visited in the past. I am sure most Jews my age share this feeling.

France may not be the best place to live in as a Jew at the moment, especially with the rise of the extreme right and the extreme left, but it is still a country that has shown support to Israel - and made me feel like I belong.

August 20, 2024 15:02

Want more from the JC?

To continue reading, we just need a few details...

Want more from
the JC?

To continue reading, we just
need a few details...

Get the best news and views from across the Jewish world Get subscriber-only offers from our partners Subscribe to get access to our e-paper and archive